Caltech Senior Physics Laboratory
Experiment 12
September 2000
This document is also available in pdf format for better printing. Get it here.
This experiment examines the interactions of g-rays and X-rays with matter, utilizing several detectors with contemporary electronic instruments and experimental techniques. Scintillation detectors contain a special material that emits light when ionizing radiation transfers energy to it. A Photomultiplier Tube (PMT) is used to convert that light to electrons and amplify them for further processing and analysis. Inorganic single crystals provide very high detection efficiency (into the GeV range) with excellent energy resolution, with organic materials providing fast response and very large devices. A semiconductor detector delivers detection efficiencies similar to inorganic crystals but with much higher energy resolution.
Figure 1. The components of a scintillation detector.
E < 1.022 MeV: Compton and Photoelectric interactions are possible. If a Compton event occurs, the incident photon transfers part of its energy to a free electron, the direction and energy of the remanent photon being changed appropriately. The amount of energy lost by the photon, and the amount transferred to the electron, varies from a very small amount (small angle scattering) to a maximum when the photon scatters at 180 degrees. In the Photoelectric interaction, all of the energy of the photon will be transferred to an electron, the incident photon disappearing. The electron carries away all of the energy minus the binding energy of the electron.
References: (1) Chap. 23 - 26; (2) Chap. 4; (3) p. 62-66.
E > 1.022 MeV: Compton and Photoelectric interactions plus another process, Pair Production. With Pair Production, a g-ray creates an electron-positron pair in the field of a nucleus, with 1.022 MeV of the g-ray energy producing the rest masses of the electron-positron pair, and the remainder appearing as kinetic energy of the pair. When the positron later comes to rest and annihilates with an electron, two 0.511-MeV photons are produced. The energy deposited in the detector can produce outputs proportional to Eg , Eg - 1.022 MeV, Eg - 0.511 MeV, or 0.511 MeV.
References: (1) Chap. 23, (2) p. 147-149, 357-360, (3) p. 67.
- Collisions, with energy transferred to the electrons of the material. (The primary mechanism for electrons and b-rays.)
- Bremsstrahlung, the emission of electromagnetic radiation by the decelerating particle. (Main source of energy loss for E > > mc2. Electron: E = 800 MeV / Z for radiation and ionization losses approximately equal.)
References: (1) Chap. 18-21; (2) Chap. 4; (3) p. 56-62.
Figure 2. Theoretical and actual spectra of detected g-rays. (a) Single g-ray < 1 MeV, (b) Double g-ray < 1 MeV, (c) Single g-ray > ~2 MeV.
Figure 3. Theoretical and actual spectra produced by a plastic scintillator from a single 1 MeV g-ray.
Figure 4. The band theory representation of an activated alkali-halide crystal scintillator.
Lattice imperfections such as vacancies, or impurity atoms that are supplied by an "activator", produce relatively low energy states in the band gap at isolated sites in the crystal lattice. The elevation of an activator atom to an excited state may result from the absorption of a photon produced by the decay of an excited state in the conduction band, the capture of a migrating electron and hole (in any order), or the capture of an exciton. The decay of an excited activator state (the predominant mode of scintillation) produces a photon in a decay time of the order of 100 ns, at a wavelength in the short blue or long UV region. Because the energy that is needed to produce an activator photon is always lower than what is required to excite a conduction band electron, very little re-absorption takes place, i.e., the parent crystal is highly transparent to the scintillation photons.
The most common alkali-halide scintillator is single crystal Sodium Iodide with about 0.1% Thallium activator content [NaI(Tl)]. It provides relatively high Z and density, with the highest currently available luminescent efficiency. Principal deficiencies are extreme toxicity from the Thallium content, mechanical fragility, and the need for a hermetic sealed enclosure for protection from water.
g-rays generate about 5 x 10 4 ion-pairs/MeV of energy deposited in NaI(Tl), giving a detection conversion efficiency of ~12%, or about 4 x 10 4 photons/Mev, with each photon having an average energy of ~3 eV, or about 1 emitted photon/ion-pair generated.
References: (2) p. 195-200; (3) p. 254-261.
Relevant parameters for NaI(Tl) are:
A Linear Attenuation Coefficient plot will be found in Appendix A .
Relevant parameters for BGO are:
A Linear Attenuation Coefficient plot will be found in Appendix A .
Figure 5. Energy diagram (simplified) of an organic scintillator.
The scintillator for this experiment, NE-102, has the following properties:
References:(2) p. 195-204, (3) p. 239-254, (4) p. 163-166.
The detector used here is a disk (3.6 cm diameter x 1.3 cm thick) of ultra-high purity (intrinsic) germanium fabricated for Low Energy Photon (LEP) spectroscopy, and mounted in a LN2 cooled cryostat with a very thin (0.25 mm Beryllium) entrance window.
The mechanism of electron-hole pair production in the detector is complicated. The references listed below provide detailed information. The following will introduce the device and permit its effective use.
g-rays and x-rays interact with a solid state detector by the same three processes previously described (Compton Scattering, Photoelectric Effect, and Pair Production) If the first interaction is a Compton event, it starts a sequence that continues until no electron has enough energy to produce additional ionization, or escapes. The number of electron-hole pairs produced is a function of dE/dX, or stopping power, and the energy required to produce an electron-hole pair (2.96 eV). The number of electron-hole pairs contributing to the output signal is determined by the charge collection efficiency, which depends on the carrier mobility (5 m2 /V•s @ 77 K), lifetime of the carriers (~1 ms), and collection time (~200 ns). This last is a function of the field gradient present, i.e., the magnitude of the bias voltage that can be applied without excessive leakage currents (noise source) or diode junction breakdown. The bias voltage must produce full "depletion" (maximum depth) to insure efficient charge collection from the entire active volume. This simultaneously reduces the detector capacitance and maximizes the signal-to-noise ratio. Cooling by liquid nitrogen to < 90 K is essential to achieve an acceptably low thermal noise level. This "Intrinsic" germanium detector does NOT suffer damage by a warm-up to room temperature.
The relevant parameters for germanium detectors are:
(Best units available) 200 to 600 eV FWHM @ 122 keV
1.7 keV FWHM @ 1.33 MeV
Plots of Linear Absorption Coefficients and Efficiency data will be found in Appendix A .
Figure 6. Electron multiplier (dynode chain/anode) system.
Figure 7. Photomultiplier resistive voltage divider components.
Figure 8. The scintillation detector electronic system.
Figure 9. The cooled Germanium detector electronic system.
If a pulse should start on the tail of a preceding pulse, rather than from true zero, energy resolution suffers. This is avoided by an automatic gated Base Line Restorer (BLR) that senses the peak of the input pulse and closes a transmission gate that rejects all following input pulses until the amplifier output can be clamped to true zero level. When the gate opens, the next pulse starts from zero. The improvement in energy resolution varies from a few percent to 5x.
A precision pulse generator produces constant amplitude (monoenergetic) pulses that accurately simulate the detector output. If the amplifier chain were noiseless, the MCA would show a pulser peak only one channel wide, and detector peaks widths would accurately represent the energy resolution of the detector. Amplifiers are not noiseless, and the pulser peak has a width proportional to this noise. Detector peaks are broadened by this noise, which adds in quadrature.
Reference: (2) p. 316-320, (5), and the manufacturer's manuals.
Figure 10. Energy resolution of NaI(Tl) and Germanium detectors. Note LOG scale.
The detectors available are: a demountable photomultiplier unit with NaI(Tl), BGO, and plastic scintillators, two integral NaI(Tl) units (1 ¾" dia. x 1 1/2" and 3" dia. x 3"), and an ultra-pure Intrinsic Germanium device with a thin entrance window designed for low energy photons (2 to 150 keV) but usable to 1 MeV and slightly above.
Instruction manuals for the instrumentation are collected in a binder at each setup. Additional copies are available for overnight borrowing. Study the material for each instrument before attempting to operate it.
Set the MCA rear panel Direct Input Coupling switch to DC (center) when a PMT is used. Check the MCA USER'S GUIDE and APPENDIX B of this write-up for the SETUP parameters to allow sending data to the computer. At least 256 Channels must be displayed on the MCA screen before a successful data transmission to the computer can be made. Only those channels actually displayed will be sent. N.B.: CONNECT ONLY THE OUTPUT CONNECTOR OF THE PMT PREAMP TO THE TENNELEC 214 AMPLIFIER INPUT CONNECTOR. That input is biased to -24V and will destroy any other device connected to it.
Connect the TC 812 pulser Attenuated Output to the TEST input of the demountable PMT base unit. Be sure to select the correct polarity. Preset the amplifier Gain controls to mid-scale, and the TC 812 PULSE HEIGHT dial to 900. Adjust amplifier gain controls, TC 812 step attenuators, and the Pulser CALIB. control (Front Panel screwdriver adjust), to set the Pulser output exactly in channel 450 (or 900) of the smallest MCA memory group available (1024 Channels). Use the MCA Cursor and Horizontal Expansion. You can then set the Pulser output to specific values with the ten-turn PULSE HEIGHT dial (non-linearity < < 0.1%). Is the response of the preamp/amplifier/MCA chain linear? Is the zero offset? If it is, a correction must be applied to data. Is this test completely valid for the measurements that are required below? Consider exactly what components have been tested.
a. Be certain that the HP 6515A High Voltage power supply is turned OFF. DISCONNECT THE HIGH VOLTAGE CABLE at the PMT tube base assembly. Remove the light shield from the photomultiplier tube base assembly by turning and lifting the shield. Attach the small NaI(Tl) crystal to the PMT faceplate using a modest quantity of fluid (Vaseline) for optical coupling. Avoid trapping any air bubbles. Replace the light shield, attach the High Voltage cable, and set the HP 6515A HV Power Supply to + 600 V (the Variable control fully counterclockwise.). Place a 137Cs source disk directly upon the entrance window of the light shield. Take a spectrum with at least 1000 counts in the highest full energy peak channel. Always use the minimum number of channels consistent with spectral detail and the detector resolution (but at least 256). Transfer data to the computer, save it to a disk file, then plot it. Finally, send the spectrum to the printer. Identify all features. What is the energy resolution (FWHM @ 662 keV) and detection efficiency @ 662 keV for the 137Cs full energy peak? Turn off the HV and disconnect the HV cable from the PMT base assembly.
b. Replace the NaI(Tl) crystal with the BGO scintillator. Retain the HV, amplifier gain, and source-detector geometry used for 2(a), take a 137Cs spectrum. If higher gain is required, change the MCA CONVERSION GAIN to accurately preserve the energy calibration (the amplifier gain switch settings are imprecise). Describe and explain the differences between the 137Cs spectra taken with the NaI(Tl) and the BGO. Compare the energy resolution, detection efficiency, and luminescent efficiency of BGO to NaI(Tl).
c. Replace the BGO scintillator with the plastic unit. Take a 137Cs spectrum. Once again use the MCA CONVERSION GAIN to adjust the span of the spectrum. Compare this spectrum with the two crystal spectra and explain the differences. Be sure you understand this spectrum, you will need it for later experiments.
a. 137Cs (Use the calibration disk directly on the detector faceplate, placing a lead plate on top of it). Set the MCA LLD as low as possible. What is the resolution (FWHM @ 662 keV) of this detector assembly? What is the detection efficiency @ 662 keV? Compare with the 137Cs spectrum of 2(a). Do you see any additional artifacts? (Hint: look at low end.) What effect(s) do(es) the lead plate produce?
b. 137Cs , as above, with a 10 V reduction in HV. Why is the shift in the photopeak position so large? Calculate the rate of change of PMT amplification with respect to changes in HV. (10-stage PMT.)
c. Change to the 3" diam x 3" Bicron integrated NaI(Tl) detector. Take a composite 137Cs /60Co spectrum with FS at about 3 MeV, keeping the HV at 800V. Use plastic foam under the source buttons, if needed, to keep the MCA Dead Time below 10%. Count long enough to accumulate more than 10000 counts in the 1.33 MeV peak channel. Identify all peaks and features (HINT: examine both the low and the high energy regions with the LOG display mode). Use the previously measured MCA Zero offset data to determine the detector/electronics linearity. Discuss your results in detail. What influence does the detector entrance window have on your data at the lowest energies? Would the results be different, and perhaps better, if separate spectra were taken for each source? Explain.
d. Take a spectrum with the 24Na source, with full scale set about 4 MeV. Ask T.A. about its location and fabrication. Check the Guide to the Table of Isotopes . Use enough channels (2048 suggested) in order to clearly delineate all features. This source is weak, requiring you to count for more than 45 minutes to obtain adequate statistics. You must seriously consider contributions from environmental background. Explain the origins and relative heights of all peaks and features. Examine the mid and high energies.
a. Change the MCA input to the Germanium detector system. This will involve moving the MCA input cable from the Tennelec 214 amplifier to the unipolar output of the EG&G ORTEC 570 amplifier. Verify that the output signal from the Ge detector is connected to the input of the Ortec 570. Set the MCA Direct Input Coupling switch to DC. Connect the TC 812 Pulse Generator to the Preamp TEST input and measure the spectral broadening caused by electronic noise. Do not try to analyze both Pulser and source data at the same time. This will produce strange and distorted peaks. Remove all sources from the vicinity of the detector when taking the Pulser spectrum, the room background will not cause problems. Do not reduce the detector bias voltage. Reduction, or removal, of the bias voltage will reduce the depletion depth of the detector, increasing the capacitance and noise drastically.
b. Set full scale at about 150 keV (2048 channels suggested), with the 57Co Calibration source. The 57Co calibration source is mounted on a small plastic stick: CAUTION: The detector's 0.25 mm beryllium entrance window is FRAGILE. The slightest touch with a warm moist finger will cause it to shatter, totally destroying the (very expensive) detector. Ask the T.A. to setup the Fluorescence source/sample geometry with the much stronger (~2 mCi) 57Co working source. This source is mounted in a lead brick to shield both people and the detector from its emissions. The sample scatterers available are: U, Pb, Ta, Pt, Ag, Sn, Cd, etc. This is a non-destructive technique for investigating materials. You may also select, or supply, materials of your own choosing. Use the 57Co and 137Cs sources to establish an accurate energy/offset/linearity calibration. Determine the energy and resolution (corrected for electronic noise) for all peaks and their relative heights. What is the effect of the detector entrance window on energy determinations? What analytic techniques will be required to obtain best results for the energy and intensity values? What is the origin of the radiation that produces the various peaks? [Check, and consider QUESTION 5.]
References: (2) Chap. 11, (3) Chap. 11, 12, and 13.
All above are available in the laboratory. Additional reference material will be found in the bookshelf, in sign-out binders, and at the experiment setup.
Figure A-2. Total linear attenuation coefficients of BGO. Data from LASL Report LA2237.
Figure A-3. Germanium absorption data.
Figure A-4. Efficiency vs. energy for a planar X-ray detector.
Figure A-5. Efficiency vs. energy for a coaxial germanium detector.
Fig. A-6. Decay scheme of 57Co.
Fig. A-7. Decay scheme of 60Co.
Fig. A-8. Decay scheme of 24Na.
Fig. A-9. Decay scheme of 137Cs.
Fig. A-10. Decay scheme of 22Na.
Instructions for file transfer between TN-7200 and Lab Personal Computer systems via Kermit or Netterm program.
SET-UP: Four of the computers in Room 210 are connected to the 4 MCAs in Room 210 via 2 data switches using a null modem. On the "COMPUTER SELECT" box, select which computer you will be using and on the "MCA SELECT" box, which experimental station data will be transferred to/from. It is strongly suggested you create your own data directory (C:\users\yourname). The particulars depend on which program you intend to use for the transfer. The primary program now used (with the Pentium II systems) is called NetTerm. Instructions for the MS-DOS program Kermit follow these paragraphs. NetTerm can be run from the Windows 98 Start menu. Click Start, Programs, NetTerm, NetTerm to run the program. By default, the program should start with the Tracor configuration. If not, select Tracor from the directory menu. Then connect, either via the command menus or by clicking the connect icon on the toolbar. The red dot in the lower left of the application window should turn green.
TRANSFER TO COMPUTER: Next, click Receive, ASCII from the NetTerm program menu. You will be prompted for a file name. Give your data file a name and specify your data directory. On the MCA, press the SETUP key and then the OUT key; press 1 to select BAUD RATE and set it to 4800. Press OUT again and press 0 to select PRINT. Select SPECTRUM, STANDARD FORMAT, and 8 columns. This will produce ASCII output which is easily read into FFIT and other programs. Remove the "header" which preceeds the numerical data if you want to open the file with Curvefit. Press SETUP once more to return to the command mode and press the OUT key. If everything has been done correctly the file will transfer to the computer. If the MCA displays the message < < TERMINAL DISCONNECTED > > then most likely one of the data switches has been set incorrectly or the wrong serial port on the computer has been selected. Some of the computers use COM2 for data transfer. After successfully transferring the spectrum, click Receive, ASCII to un-check ASCII. This closes the file. For some unknown reason, the file may not be read by another application until NetTerm is exited.
TRANSFER TO TN-7200: On the MCA, select a memory group to accept the incoming data, then press the SETUP key and then the IN key; press "1" to select BAUD RATE and set it to 4800. Press SETUP twice, then press "IN" again and then "0" to select READ. Press SETUP once more to return to the command mode and press the "IN" key. Open the data file with a text editor, such as Notepad. Remove any leading blank lines (Not including the TN-7200 ... line), then Select All and Copy it to the clipboard. In the NetTerm window, Connect to Tracor, then Paste the data (which will not appear in the NetTerm window). If everything has been done correctly the file will transfer to the TN-7200 (you can watch its progress on the MCA screen). If the MCA displays the message < < TERMINAL DISCONNECTED > > then most likely one of the data switches has been set incorrectly or the wrong serial port on the computer has been selected.
KERMIT SETUP: After having selected MCA and computer via switches, get into the Kermit directory on the computer (using the CD name and DIR commands to change directory to "name" and to view the contents of the directory) and then type KERMIT. In Windows, double-click on the Kermit icon to start Kermit. You can then CD \users\yourname while Kermit is running. The computer baud rate and COM port settings are specified in the Kermit initialization file. If incorrect, type the command SET BAUD 4800.
KERMIT TRANSFER TO COMPUTER: At the MS-Kermit> prompt change into your user directory then type LOG SESSION name where name is the filename of the file to be received. Then type C to connect to the TN-7200. Proceed with the MCA setup as above. If the transfer is successful, when it is done type < CTRL > - ] C to get out of terminal mode on the computer and then type CLOSE SESSION to save the file. ( < CTRL > - ] is one keystroke, followed by C for "close"). You can quit Kermit by typing Q.
KERMIT TRANSFER TO TN-7200: Setup the MCA for input as above. At the MS-KERMIT > prompt type TRANSMIT name where "name" is the filename of the file to be sent. If the transfer is successful, when it is done type < CTRL > - ] C to get out of terminal mode on the computer. You can quit Kermit by typing Q.
Last updated 10 August, 2000.
Broken links fixed 25 July, 2000.
1. MCA Linearity And Zero Offset Tests:
2. Comparison Of Scintillator Types:
3. Spectral Analysis With A NaI(Tl) Detector:
4. X-Ray Fluorescence Analysis With A Low Energy Photon (LEP) Detector:
Questions
References
Appendix A


Appendix B